How to Handle Bad Faith Insurance Claims After a Car Accident

Leo

July 31, 2025

Bad Faith

Car accidents are stressful enough without the added burden of an insurance company acting unfairly. Unfortunately, some insurers delay, underpay, or wrongfully deny valid claims. If you face these issues, speaking with a bad faith insurance lawyer early on can help protect your rights and hold your insurer accountable.

What Is Bad Faith in Insurance?

Understanding what qualifies as bad faith is the first step in holding insurers accountable. Many policyholders aren’t aware that certain actions—like ignoring valid evidence or offering unjustifiably low settlements—may be legally actionable. Educating yourself early can help you respond confidently if your claim is mishandled.

Common Tactics Used by Insurers

Unjustified denials, unreasonable delays, lowball offers, and misleading policy information are frustrating and often illegal behaviors that can wear claimants down. These tactics are designed to pressure you into accepting less than you deserve or giving up entirely. Reviewing resources like South Carolina car accident FAQs can help you understand your rights and recognize when these tactics cross the line. Recognizing them early allows you to push back and protect your financial recovery confidently.

Recognizing the Signs

Watch for:

Delays without explanation, repeated requests for the same documents, pressure to settle quickly, and vague denials lacking claim details are common issues. These red flags suggest your insurer may not be acting in good faith. Keeping detailed records of every interaction can help you build a stronger case if you decide to take further action.

What to Do If You Suspect Bad Faith

Keep detailed records, review your policy, demand written explanations, file a complaint with your state’s insurance regulator, and seek legal help if informal efforts fail. These steps show your insurer that you’re informed and serious about your claim. Acting early can prevent further delays and strengthen your position if legal action becomes necessary.

Legal Remedies

You may be entitled to:

  • Contract Damages for unpaid claims
  • Bad Faith Damages for emotional distress or punitive action
  • Statutory Penalties, depending on your state

Prevention Tips

  • Understand your policy in detail
  • Save accident-related documents and communications
  • Communicate in writing to create a paper trail

Conclusion

Don’t stay silent if you believe your insurer is acting in bad faith. Know your rights, stay organized, and consult professionals when needed. Taking action now protects your recovery and helps prevent future abuse.

Even large insurance companies can be held accountable when policyholders assert their rights. Your persistence could also encourage industry-wide changes that promote fair treatment for others.